This information is current as of the date of original publication or update. It may have changed by the time you read this. I invite you to fact-check what you read here.
Please do not use this information for diagnosis or treatment purposes. Before making health decisions, discuss with your physician or other qualified healthcare provider.
Pain Treatment: A Problem for Doctors and Patients
When I was practicing medicine, pain was one of the most difficult problems to manage. I had to balance the need to relieve a person’s pain while not creating dependence or addiction.
Sometimes patients came to me already on chronic opioids for pain. I had to decide whether to continue them or change the person to another treatment, which can be hard to do. Sometimes patients came to me requesting “something” for pain. Only by checking the state pharmacy database did I learn they were already receiving prescriptions for opiates from other physicians, sometimes several.
In my long medical career, there have been few non opiate alternatives for severe pain. So I am pleased to learn of a new drug which is exactly that. Unfortunately, its use may be limited due to cost. This article explains how states are trying to circumvent that problem.
(For the purpose of this article, consider the terms narcotic, opiate, and opioid as referring to the same type of drug.)
More states are requiring insurers to cover non-opioid pain meds
by Nada Hassanein, Oklahoma Voice
February 16, 2026
(edited for readability and clarity, no change to content)
More states are requiring their Medicaid programs and health insurance companies to cover non-opioid pain medications as an alternative to opioids, which can be cheaper for insurers but also more addictive for patients.
Advocates, providers, medical associations, and state lawmakers are pushing for parity in coverage. That means prohibiting insurers from charging higher copayments for non-opioids than they do for opioids, and barring them from requiring prior authorization or step therapy — mandating that patients try other medications first — before they will cover non-opioid drugs.
At least eight states have enacted such laws: Arkansas, Illinois, Louisiana, Maine, Massachusetts, Oklahoma, Oregon, and Tennessee. In states that are still considering legislation, the efforts have been bipartisan, pushed by lawmakers in some Democratic-controlled states, Colorado and New York, and some Republican-leaning states, Kentucky and Missouri.
The issue has gained momentum in recent years, as leading medical associations such as the American Society of Regional Anesthesia and Pain Medicine have urged providers not to prescribe opioids as the first-line treatment for pain.
Meanwhile, bipartisan legislation introduced in Congress last year aims to increase Medicaid Part D enrollees’ access to non-opioid pain medications. It’s been referred to a committee.
Dr. Patrick Giam, president of the American Society of Anesthesiologists, said the organization “believes it is important that insurance plans make non-opioid therapies as accessible to patients as opioid-based therapies.”
drugs to treat pain
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has encouraged non-opioid pain relief alternatives.
Non-opioid pain medications include
- prescription-strength non-steroid anti-inflammatory NSAIDs such as naproxen and ibuprofen,
- nerve-blocking injections,
- certain antidepressants,
- anticonvulsant medications,
- acetaminophen , such as Tylenol and other brands, and
- other medications.
(affiliate links)
Opioids include
- oxycodone,
- codeine,
- morphine and
- fentanyl.
suzetrigine-Journavx
Last year, the agency approved a new drug called suzetrigine, under the brand name Journavx, the first non-opioid pain relief medication in a new class of analgesic drugs. The drug, which is available in tablets, can be prescribed for acute pain after surgery or injury. Vertex Pharmaceuticals, the manufacturer, is one of the funders of Voices for Non-Opioid Choices, which has been lobbying for the bills.
In Missouri, where GOP-sponsored legislation would prohibit insurance companies from denying coverage of a prescribed non-opioid or requiring a higher copayment for a non-opioid, the Missouri Insurance Coalition has argued that the measure would increase health care costs and effectively create “a monopoly” for Journavx. Each tablet can cost around $15 per tablet out-of-pocket. But lawmakers pointed to non-opioid alternatives.
Why non-opioids often cost more
Newer non-opioid drugs entering the market are more expensive than opioids because there isn’t yet a generic alternative, explained Sterling Elliott, an Illinois clinical pharmacist and lecturer at Northwestern University’s Feinberg School of Medicine and a board member of Voices for Non-Opioid Choices.
Generic opioids are amongst the cheapest medications that you’ll find flowing through the American pharmaceutical supply,
Sterling Elliott, clinical pharmacist
“The price is so high for a lot of things because the price for generic opioids is so low. Generic opioids are amongst the cheapest medications that you’ll find flowing through the American pharmaceutical supply,” Elliott said. “When you get a new entrant into the pain market, the marketplace factors are set up to drive the price up.”
Elliott added that some insurance plans don’t cover prescription-strength NSAIDs such as ibuprofen because they’d rather people pay out-of-pocket for lower strength, over-the-counter versions of those drugs.
In New York, Democratic Assembly member Phil Steck, the cosponsor of a bipartisan bill that hasn’t received a hearing, said challenging the insurance companies isn’t easy.
“You’re trying to tell insurers what to do,” Steck said. “Those are usually difficult undertakings. … Our experience is that the [legislature’s] insurance committee is very difficult to deal with, and so it hasn’t been pursued as much as we would like.”
Coverage of non-opioids can vary widely across insurance plans, explained clinical pharmacist Emma Murter, who co-chairs the advocacy committee of the Society of Pain and Palliative Care Pharmacists.
“There are so many [non-opioid] medications that can be used for chronic pain,” Murter said. “It isn’t gut-instinct obvious, what is and isn’t covered. It’s very Wild West, chaotic.”
When it comes to filling prescriptions, Murter said, she often has to “fight and appeal for some of these non-opioid therapies” with insurance companies.
Dima Qato, associate professor of clinical pharmacy at the University of Southern California, said non-opioid pain prescription meds are less common on insurance companies’ “preferred” drug lists. Because insurers may favor the less expensive opioids, that can result in higher copayments or consumers paying more out-of-pocket.
That was the case for Chris Fox, the Washington lobbyist who serves as executive director of Voices for Non-Opioid Choices. Fox has traveled to state capitals around the country to lobby for the bills. Recently, he had a personal experience with pain medications following oral surgery.
“For everything but the non-opioid, my out-of-pocket expectation was $0,” he said. He was charged $30 out-of-pocket for the non-opioid.
His oral surgeon wasn’t familiar with the availability of the new first-in-class non-opioid suzetrigine, Fox added. When he asked the doctor for a prescription for it, the surgeon wrote it but also prescribed an opioid along with an antibiotic.
“He prescribed me hydrocodone to go along with it, just in case, because he wasn’t as familiar with [suzetrigine],” Fox said.
Preventing addiction
As he spoke with Stateline by phone, Fox was driving to the local sheriff’s office to drop off the hydrocodone, which he didn’t take following his surgery.
“We’ve neglected the opportunity, I would say, to prevent opioid addiction where we can, which is in those patients that will develop a newly persistent opioid use pattern following exposure to an opioid that they get for medical reason,” Fox said.
Although opioid overdose deaths have declined, the drugs still kill about 200 Americans a day.
Health care professionals at hospitals also run into issues with lower reimbursement rates for some non-opioids.
Dr. Joseph Smith, an anesthesiologist at a Virginia surgical center who has practiced for three decades, pointed to a nerve-block pain pump as an example. Administering a brand-name version of the drug could cost up to $400 for all the equipment, he said. Smith, like Elliott, sits on the board of Voices for Non-Opioid Choices.
“So the hospital is like, ‘Well, I can spend $400 or I can spend 25 cents on a narcotic pill,’” Smith said.
Smith treats many young teen athletes with sports injuries. Research has shown post-surgery narcotic use can increase risk of addiction.
“My goal when I get a 14-year-old or 15-year-old in here is to never have them try a narcotic, never have them exposed to narcotics,” he said.
Stateline reporter Nada Hassanein can be reached at nhassanein@stateline.org.
This story was originally produced by Stateline, which is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network which includes Oklahoma Voice, and is supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity.
It is shared here under a Creative Commons License.
Tolerance vs. Dependence vs. Addiction
Long-term use of prescription opioids, even as prescribed by a doctor, can cause some people to develop a tolerance, which means that they need higher and/or more frequent doses of the drug to get the desired effects.
Drug dependence occurs with repeated use, causing the neurons to adapt so they only function normally in the presence of the drug. The absence of the drug causes several physiological reactions, ranging from mild in the case of caffeine, to potentially life threatening, such as with heroin. Some chronic pain patients are dependent on opioids and require medical support to stop taking the drug.
Drug addiction is a chronic disease characterized by compulsive, or uncontrollable, drug seeking and use despite harmful consequences and long-lasting changes in the brain. The changes can result in harmful behaviors by those who misuse drugs, whether prescription or illicit drugs.
Source:
NIDA. Prescription Opioids DrugFacts. National Institute on Drug Abuse website. https://nida.nih.gov/publications/drugfacts/prescription-opioids. June 1, 2021 Accessed February 19, 2026.
Images in this Post
The infographics in this post were created by the NIH, National Institutes of Health, and used with permission.
The cover photo is by Towfiqu Barbhuiya and used courtesy of Pexels.com.
Get Help with Substance Use at FindTreatment.gov
While the initial choice to use a drug is often voluntary, the powerful effects of addiction makes it very hard to stop, even if someone wants to.
When drugs or alcohol are used so often that they have significant negative effects on your life, this is called a substance use disorder.
It causes intense cravings for alcohol or drugs, and can include:
- Using illegal drugs like heroin or cocaine, or excessive alcohol drinking.
- Using prescription drugs in ways other than prescribed, or using someone else’s prescription.
Using drugs repeatedly changes the brain, including the parts that help exert self-control. That’s why someone may not be able to stop using drugs, even if they know the drug is causing harm, or want to stop.
FindTreatment.gov lists facilities across the country. It gives guidance on what to expect from treatment, different kinds of treatment, and how to pay for treatment.
If you live outside the United States, contact your local source of medical care or search online for substance use treatment in your country.
Exploring the HEART of Health
I’d love for you to follow this blog. I share information and inspiration to help you transform challenges into opportunities for learning and growth.
Add your name to the subscribe box to be notified of new posts by email. Click the link to read the post and browse other content. It’s that simple. No spam.
I enjoy seeing who is new to Watercress Words. When you subscribe, I will visit your blog or website. Thanks and see you next time.
Search this blog for related posts on this topic or other issues you care about.
Dr. Aletha
- About Dr. Aletha
- How to Use this Site
- Make Your Life Easier
- Search by Category
- Share the HEART of health
- my Reader Rewards Club
- RoboForm Password Manager
watercress words by Dr Aletha 